Skip to main content
Apragya AIFree quotation builderQuotation builderQuote builderno signup
Comparison

ERPNext Audit Trail vs Apragya: Version History You Configure, or a Log That Is Always On

For finance heads and IT leads at Indian manufacturers running or evaluating ERPNext who want an audit trail that needs little setup to be complete.

A finance manager reading a file beside a filing cabinet in a workshop office

ERPNext audit trail questions often come from companies preparing for a statutory audit. ERPNext is an open source ERP built on the Frappe framework, used widely by Indian manufacturers and traders, and it can keep a version history of changes on documents where change tracking is turned on.

Its submit, cancel and amend pattern also keeps cancelled documents visible. How complete the trail is depends on how your deployment is configured and maintained, so check with your implementation partner.

This page compares the two approaches, walks through an illustrative manufacturer and says who should stay with ERPNext.

An example: a Rajkot engine parts manufacturer

Take an illustrative manufacturer with 220 staff, closing its books quarterly. The auditor asked for every change to supplier bank details in the year, after a payment went to a wrong account at another company.

One quarter, from close to audit

  1. Quarter closed

    Posting refused after close.
  2. Log filtered

    Supplier record changes pulled.
  3. Changes read

    Who edited each supplier, and when.
  4. Approvals checked

    Each change had a reviewer.
  5. Export shared

    CSV sent to the auditor.
The audit request becomes a filter and an export, not a hunt.

Two edits to the affected supplier turned up in the year, each with the named user, the time and the IP address. Account numbers were stored encrypted and shown only as the last four digits. The auditor closed the query the same afternoon.

Hands placing a padlock on a closed folder on a shelf
Once the quarter was closed, nothing more could be posted into it, and the log showed who tried.

Where a configured audit trail can fall short

Tracking left off

Change tracking is enabled on some document types and not others.

Upgrades and custom code

Custom scripts can change records in ways the history misses.

Direct database edits

A quick fix at the database level leaves no trail.

Evidence gathered late

Version entries are compiled by hand when the auditor asks.

How the audit trail works in Apragya

Step 1 of 5

Who, what and when

Every change request is logged with the user, role, action, record, time and IP address.

  1. Who, what and when: Every change request is logged with the user, role, action, record, time and IP address.
  2. Record timeline: Records keep a timeline of creation, status changes, approvals and agent runs.
  3. Integrity check: Every log entry carries a keyed check, so a later edit to the log is detectable.
  4. Posted means fixed: Posted journals are never edited or deleted; they are voided with a reason or reversed.
  5. Search and export: Admins filter the log by user, action or record and export it as CSV or JSON.

Choosing audit trail software in India

ERPNext suits companies that want an open source ERP they can shape, with a team to configure and maintain it, including its change tracking. Apragya suits companies that want the log always on across every app, without deciding document by document.

ERPNext and Apragya on audit trail

FeatureERPNextApragya
How it is enabledChange tracking set per document typeAlways on for actions across apps
Cancelled or posted recordsCancel and amend keeps originalsVoid or reverse with a linked entry
Tamper evidenceDepends on your hostingKeyed integrity check on each entry
Supplier bank numbersCheck your configurationStored encrypted, last four shown
ExportReports you configureCSV or JSON for admins

Checked against public information on 16 September 2026.

What sets Apragya's tamper proof audit log apart

Integrity check

Later edits to a log entry can be detected.

Every app

Purchase, HR, payroll, CRM and accounts share one log.

Closed periods

Posting into a closed period is refused.

Sub-feature access

Deleting drafts or reversing entries are separate permissions.

Agent actions

AI agent runs are recorded alongside user actions.

Hosting choice

Cloud, or VPC and on-premise for Enterprise.

See Apragya vs ERPNext, API access in Apragya vs ERPNext and the ERPNext alternative page.

Testing an audit trail

  1. List the records your auditor asks about most.
  2. Change one of each in a test company.
  3. Check the log shows the user, the record and the time.
  4. Close a test period and try to post into it.
  5. Export the log and review it with the auditor.

A short test in a copy of your data avoids surprises in the audit.

What it costs to start

Free
Up to 3 users
CRM, HR and Vendor Onboarding
INR 3,999
Starter, a month
Up to 10 users, CRM and HR plus a choice of apps
INR 7,999
Pro, a month
Up to 25 users and every enterprise app

ERPNext audit trail and Apragya, answered

Should we stay with ERPNext?
If your team configures change tracking well, controls custom code and your auditor is satisfied, staying is reasonable.
Does Apragya need tracking switched on per record type?
No. Actions across the apps are logged without per-document setup.
Can we move from ERPNext at a period start?
Yes. Masters, open balances and open documents are imported from ERPNext's exports, with a parallel month.
Is the log itself protected?
Each entry carries a keyed integrity check, so a later edit to it can be detected.
Does Apragya meet the Companies Act rule?
Apragya keeps a named, timestamped log of changes with an integrity check on each entry. Your auditor should confirm whether a setup meets the rule.
What does it cost to start?
The free plan covers up to 3 users with CRM, HR and Vendor Onboarding and 1,000 AI Credits a month. Starter is INR 3,999 a month for up to 10 users, with CRM and HR plus a choice of apps such as Sales and POS, Inventory, Payroll, Purchase and Payables, Support and Manufacturing. Pro is INR 7,999 a month for up to 25 users with every enterprise app, including Finance and Accounting, plus 5,000 AI Credits, single sign-on and audit logs.

An audit trail you do not have to switch on

Make a test change in Apragya and read the log it leaves.