Skip to main content
Apragya AIFree quotation builderQuotation builderQuote builderno signup
Concept guide

Bill of Supply vs Tax Invoice: What Is the Difference Under GST?

For traders, retailers and accountants who issue both kinds of document: know which one each sale needs and let the invoice pick the right format.

A shopkeeper handing a bill to a customer across a fabric shop counter

Bill of supply vs tax invoice is a question that comes up the day a business sells something that carries no GST, or registers under the composition scheme. The two documents look alike on paper, but one charges tax and passes on credit, and the other must not.

Issuing a tax invoice when you are not allowed to collect tax, or a bill of supply for a taxable sale, creates problems for both sides: a buyer claiming credit that should not exist, or tax that was due and never shown.

This guide explains the rule, the details each document needs, an illustrative Jaipur example, and how Apragya chooses the format from the company and the items sold.

The difference in plain terms

A tax invoice is issued by a registered person for a taxable supply. It shows the GST charged, the rate, the HSN or SAC, the place of supply and both parties' details where the buyer is registered. A registered buyer can use it to claim input tax credit, subject to the usual conditions.

A bill of supply is issued where the seller cannot charge tax: by a taxpayer under the composition scheme, or by a regular taxpayer for exempt or nil-rated supplies. It shows no GST, and a composition dealer must add the declaration that they cannot collect tax.

When a regular taxpayer sells both taxable and exempt goods to an unregistered buyer, the rules allow a single invoice-cum-bill of supply. Check the current invoice rules for small-value relaxations before relying on them.

  1. Tax invoice: GST charged, credit available to a registered buyer.
  2. Bill of supply: no GST, used by composition dealers and for exempt supplies.
  3. Mixed sale to an unregistered buyer: one invoice-cum-bill of supply.

What the wrong document costs

Tax collected wrongly

A composition dealer shows GST on a bill and faces a demand.

Blocked credit

A buyer's credit is questioned because the document type was wrong.

Mismatched returns

Sales reported in the wrong table of the return.

Rework

Documents cancelled and reissued after the customer spots the error.

An illustrative example: a Jaipur handicrafts and textiles shop

Take an illustrative regular-scheme shop in Jaipur that sells printed fabric, which is taxable, and a few items that are exempt. Most carts mix both. Now and then a customer buys only exempt items, and the counter used to print a tax invoice with a zero tax line anyway.

An all-exempt sale, billed correctly

Bill of supply

  1. A regular taxpayer, so this depends on the items.

  2. Every line is marked exempt on the item master.

  3. No GST amount appears anywhere on the document.

  4. Numbered separately from tax invoices.

  5. A bill of supply is not e-invoiced.

  6. Add one taxable item and a tax invoice is issued.

The items decided the document, not the cashier.

All-exempt sales now print as bills of supply in their own series, and mixed carts print as tax invoices with the exempt lines carrying no tax. The accountant stopped cancelling documents at month end, and the return showed exempt sales where they belong.

Two different bills side by side next to a folded printed fabric
One sheet carries tax and one does not, and the items in the cart decided which was printed.

How Apragya issues the right tax invoice format under GST

Step 1 of 5

Company settings

The company's GST scheme is known, including composition.

  1. Company settings: The company's GST scheme is known, including composition.
  2. Item tax: Each item carries its HSN and its taxable or exempt status.
  3. Document type: A bill of supply for composition companies or all-exempt sales.
  4. Place of supply: Worked out from the buyer's state for taxable lines.
  5. Returns: Sales flow into GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B from the same invoices.

Composition dealer invoice rules, compared

A shop that registers under composition, or sells mostly exempt goods, should not depend on cashiers remembering which pad to use. Apragya decides the format from the company and the items, so the counter only scans and bills.

Manual billing, against Apragya

FeaturePre-printed padsApragya Sales and POS
Choosing the formatCashier decidesDecided by the GST scheme and the items
Composition dealersTax pads used by mistakeEvery sale issued as a bill of supply
Exempt linesTax sometimes added by mistakeNo tax on exempt items
HSN on each lineOften missingTaken from the item
ReturnsTyped from the padsBuilt from the same invoices

Checked against public information on 16 September 2026.

What sets Apragya apart

One record

The customer, the stock and the ledger see the same invoice.

AI you can put to work

An agent can flag items with no HSN before billing.

Counter and office

The same rules in the POS till and the back office.

Access by role

Cashiers bill; only accounts can change tax settings.

E-invoice guard

Tax invoices get an IRN where required; bills of supply are refused one.

Own number series

Bills of supply are numbered apart from tax invoices.

See sales invoices, the POS till and our GST composition scheme guide.

Getting started

  1. Confirm the company's GST scheme: regular or composition.
  2. Mark each item as taxable, nil-rated or exempt, with its HSN.
  3. Set up document number series for each type you issue.
  4. Run a few test bills for mixed and exempt sales.
  5. Check the draft GSTR-1 before the first filing.

Most errors come from item masters, so the item list is the best place to spend the first hour.

What it costs to start

INR 3,999
Starter, a month
Up to 10 users, CRM and HR plus Sales and POS
2,000
AI Credits a month
Included on Starter
Free
Up to 3 users
CRM, HR and Vendor Onboarding

Bill of supply under GST, answered

Can a composition dealer issue a tax invoice?
No. A composition taxpayer cannot collect tax from customers and issues a bill of supply with the composition declaration on it.
Can a regular taxpayer issue a bill of supply?
Yes, for exempt or nil-rated supplies, and a combined invoice-cum-bill of supply for a mixed sale to an unregistered buyer.
Does a bill of supply need HSN codes?
Include them. HSN reporting applies to the return, and it is simpler to carry them on every document.
Can the buyer claim input tax credit on a bill of supply?
No. No tax is charged on it, so there is no credit to claim.
What does it cost to start?
Sales and POS is available from the Starter plan, INR 3,999 a month for up to 10 users, which includes CRM and HR plus a choice of enterprise apps and 2,000 AI Credits a month. Pro, at INR 7,999 a month, covers 25 users and every enterprise app.

Let the invoice choose its own format

Set your GST scheme and items once, and every sale prints the right document.