New vs Old Tax Regime: Rules, Calculation and How Employers Should Handle the Choice
For salaried employees, HR and payroll teams: how the two regimes differ, how to compare them for one person, and how to run TDS on the regime each employee picks.
The new vs old tax regime question comes up every April. Employees ask which one is better, payroll needs a declared choice to deduct tax, and the answer depends on each person's deductions rather than a general rule.
The new regime is the default. It has lower slab rates and a larger standard deduction, but it drops most exemptions and deductions. The old regime keeps them, at higher rates. Which one saves more tax depends on how much a person actually claims.
This guide sets out the rules as they generally apply, a worked comparison, and how Apragya records each employee's choice and deducts TDS on it.
New vs old tax regime: the rules that matter
The new regime has been the default since 2023-24. An individual without business income can choose the old regime instead each year; for salary TDS, the employee tells the employer which regime to deduct on. The Income-tax Act, 2025 applies from 1 April 2026 and renumbers sections, but the choice between the two regimes continues.
Under the new regime, most exemptions and deductions are not available: HRA, leave travel, the investment deduction, health insurance and interest on a self-occupied home loan among them. In return, slab rates are lower and the standard deduction is larger. In recent years the standard deduction has been 75,000 rupees in the new regime against 50,000 in the old, and a rebate has made taxable income up to 12 lakh effectively tax free for residents under the new regime.
To compare, work out taxable income under each regime, apply that regime's slabs, rebate, surcharge and cess, and compare the totals. The worked example below uses the 2025-26 slabs; always check the current Finance Act before you rely on a figure.
A rough rule: the more deductions a person genuinely claims, the more the old regime is worth checking. For many employees without a home loan or rent, the new regime is lower.
- List the employee's real exemptions and deductions.
- Work out taxable income under each regime.
- Apply each regime's slabs, rebate and cess.
- Compare the two totals.
- Declare the chosen regime to payroll.
What a mishandled regime choice costs
Wrong TDS
Tax deducted on the wrong regime all year, corrected in a painful March.
Surprise demands
Employees face a tax payment when they file, and blame payroll.
Proof chaos
Old regime proofs collected late, with no link to what was declared.
Year-end crunch
HR recomputes tax for everyone in the last month.
An example: a Hyderabad engineer comparing regimes
Take an illustrative engineer on a gross salary of 18 lakh rupees. Under the old regime she can claim HRA exemption of 2.4 lakh, 1.5 lakh of investments, 25,000 of health insurance and 2 lakh of home loan interest, plus the standard deduction.
The same salary, worked through both regimes
Gross salary
18 lakh rupees for the year.
Old regime deductions
6.65 lakh in total, so 11.35 lakh taxable.
New regime deduction
Standard deduction only, so 17.25 lakh taxable.
Tax compared
About 1,59,000 old against 1,51,000 new.
Choice recorded
New regime, declared to payroll in April.
Using the slabs that applied for 2025-26, including cess, the old regime came to about 1,59,000 rupees and the new regime to about 1,51,000. She chose the new regime, payroll deducted on it from April, and she did not need to submit investment proofs in January.
How payroll handles a tax regime for salaried employees in Apragya
Step 1 of 5
Record the choice
Each employee's regime is stored for the tax year.
- Record the choice: Each employee's regime is stored for the tax year.
- Preview the tax: A what-if calculation shows the tax for a given regime, salary and exemptions.
- Flag missing choices: A payroll run lists employees with no choice, who fall to the default regime.
- Collect proofs: Declarations and proofs are submitted by employees and verified by HR.
- Lock at finalise: Finalising a run locks the regime for the year, so it cannot drift.
Which tax regime is better, and how to decide
There is no universal answer. Someone with a home loan, rent and full investments may still save with the old regime; many others will not. The honest approach is to compare the two for each employee and let them decide, with payroll deducting on that choice.
Handling regime choices by email, against Apragya
| Feature | Email and spreadsheet | Apragya |
|---|---|---|
| Employee choice | Collected in a form | Stored per employee per year |
| Tax preview | Each person's own calculator | What-if preview on the same rules as payroll |
| Missing choices | Found in March | Listed on every payroll run |
| Proofs | Email attachments | Submitted and verified on the record |
| Year-end documents | Built by hand | Quarterly return and annual certificate from payroll data |
Checked against public information on 16 September 2026.
What sets Apragya apart for regime handling
One employee record
Salary, declarations, proofs and TDS in one place.
Rules as data
Slabs and exemption categories are stored as configuration, not code.
AI with human review
An agent can explain a payslip's TDS line, for payroll to confirm.
Self-service
Employees see payslips and submit declarations from the phone-friendly app.
Role-based access
Only payroll can change a locked choice, and it is logged.
No year-end surprise
Tax is projected every month, so March is not a shock.
Regime handling feeds TDS computation and the annual payroll cycle in payroll software for India. For the step-by-step setup, see how to automate new vs old tax regime.
Getting started
- Ask every employee to declare a regime at the start of the year.
- Share a simple comparison for those who are unsure.
- Record the choices before the first payroll run.
- Collect declarations only from old regime employees.
- Verify proofs before the last quarter's deductions.
Most employees decide quickly once they see their own numbers side by side.
What it costs to start
New vs old tax regime, answered
Can an employee change regime during the year?
What happens if an employee does not choose?
Is the employer's NPS contribution allowed in the new regime?
Are these slab figures current?
What does it cost to start?
Deduct tax on the regime each employee chose
Record choices, preview tax and run payroll on the same rules.