Skip to main content
Apragya AIFree quotation builderQuotation builderQuote builderno signup
Comparison

Tally Audit Trail vs Apragya: The Edit Log in Your Books, or a Log Across the Business

For owners and accountants of Indian SMEs on Tally who want to understand what an audit trail looks like when purchase, payroll and sales run in the same platform.

An accountant and a partner looking at a voucher in a leather workshop office

Tally audit trail questions became common after the Companies (Accounts) Rules began, from April 2023, to require an edit log that cannot be switched off. Tally is the accounting software most Indian SMEs know, and TallyPrime offers an edit log for companies that need one.

For most businesses on Tally, the edit log covers the books well. The question is what happens to changes made outside Tally, in order sheets, payroll files and approval chats.

This page compares the two approaches, walks through an illustrative exporter and says who should stay with Tally. Check the current edit log options with Tally and your auditor.

An example: a Kanpur leather goods exporter

Take an illustrative exporter with 260 staff, shipping wallets and belts to buyers abroad. The auditor asked for every deleted accounting entry in the third quarter and who deleted it.

The auditor's deletion query

Log extract

  1. Filtered by date.

  2. Filtered by action.

  3. Posted entries cannot go.

  4. Each with the permission.

  5. Kept with the audit papers.

The query is a filter and an export, and the answer is short.

Every deletion was a draft, removed by one of two people allowed to do so. Posted entries that needed correcting had been voided with reasons or reversed, and the auditor sampled those next.

Sealed voucher slips in a column and two unsealed slips in a tray
Every deletion in the quarter was a draft, and each one named the person who removed it.

Where changes escape the books

Order sheets

Rates and quantities change in a sheet before a voucher exists.

Payroll files

Salary edits happen in a separate tool or file.

Approvals in chat

A manager's yes lives in a phone, not on the record.

Shared logins

One login for the whole team hides who did what.

How the audit trail works in Apragya

Step 1 of 5

Who, what and when

Every change request is logged with the user, role, action, record, time and IP address.

  1. Who, what and when: Every change request is logged with the user, role, action, record, time and IP address.
  2. Record timeline: Records keep a timeline of creation, status changes, approvals and agent runs.
  3. Integrity check: Every log entry carries a keyed check, so a later edit to the log is detectable.
  4. Posted means fixed: Posted journals are never edited or deleted; they are voided with a reason or reversed.
  5. Search and export: Admins filter the log by user, action or record and export it as CSV or JSON.

Choosing an audit trail for small business in India

Tally is a sound choice for books and GST, and its edit log may be all a small company needs. Apragya suits businesses that want orders, payroll, approvals and accounts in one platform, so the trail covers the work around the vouchers too.

Tally and Apragya on audit trail

FeatureTallyApragya
ScopeAccounting data in the edit logChange requests across every app
ApprovalsUsually outside the softwareRecorded on the record
Posted entriesCheck the current releaseVoided with a reason or reversed
Integrity of the logCheck the current releaseKeyed check on each entry
Moving overNot applicableAssisted Tally migration at a period start

Checked against public information on 16 September 2026.

What sets Apragya apart on the Tally edit log question

Beyond vouchers

Orders, payroll and approvals share the same trail.

Assisted Tally migration

Masters and balances moved at a period start.

Named permissions

Deleting a draft journal is its own permission.

Closed periods

Posting into a closed period is refused.

Integrity check

Later edits to log entries can be detected.

Phone-friendly web app

Approvals from the phone, recorded on the record.

See the Tally alternative, approval workflows in Apragya vs Tally and AI agents in Apragya vs Tally.

Testing an audit trail beyond the books

  1. List changes your auditor asked about last year.
  2. Mark which ones happened outside Tally.
  3. Run one of those processes on Apragya for a month.
  4. Filter the log for that process and export it.
  5. Compare the evidence with what you had before.

The changes made outside the books are usually where audit queries start.

What it costs to start

Free
Up to 3 users
CRM, HR and Vendor Onboarding
INR 3,999
Starter, a month
Up to 10 users, CRM and HR plus a choice of apps
INR 7,999
Pro, a month
Up to 25 users and every enterprise app

Tally audit trail and Apragya, answered

Should we stay with Tally?
If your work is mostly accounting and GST and your auditor is satisfied with the edit log, staying is reasonable.
How do we move from Tally?
Assisted migration brings masters and balances across at a period start, followed by a parallel month.
Can posted entries be deleted in Apragya?
No. Posted journals are voided with a reason or reversed, and only drafts can be deleted by users with that permission.
Can we run Tally and Apragya together for a while?
Yes. A parallel month is the usual way to compare results before switching.
Does Apragya meet the Companies Act rule?
Apragya keeps a named, timestamped log of changes with an integrity check on each entry. Your auditor should confirm whether a setup meets the rule.
What does it cost to start?
The free plan covers up to 3 users with CRM, HR and Vendor Onboarding and 1,000 AI Credits a month. Starter is INR 3,999 a month for up to 10 users, with CRM and HR plus a choice of apps such as Sales and POS, Inventory, Payroll, Purchase and Payables, Support and Manufacturing. Pro is INR 7,999 a month for up to 25 users with every enterprise app, including Finance and Accounting, plus 5,000 AI Credits, single sign-on and audit logs.

Put the work around your vouchers on the trail

Run one process on Apragya for a month and export its log.