Tally GST Filing vs Apragya: Returns Built From the Same Records, Then Locked Once Filed
For accountants, CAs and owners of Tally-run businesses: see how return preparation differs, and whether moving GST work off the books-only desk is worth it.
Tally GST filing is how a great many Indian SMEs meet their monthly return deadlines. TallyPrime is the accounting and inventory software many accountants learnt on, and it has long produced GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B from vouchers. Recent releases add connected features for working with the GST portal, so check what your release and partner offer.
Apragya takes a different route. Invoices, bills and payments are raised in sales, purchase and accounts apps that share one record, and the returns are built from those records. The return is prepared, checked, exported for upload and then locked.
This page compares the two approaches with an illustrative example, and says who should stay with Tally.
Where monthly GST work goes wrong
Returns that disagree
GSTR-3B typed from a summary that does not match GSTR-1.
Credit claimed too early
Input tax taken before the supplier's invoice shows in GSTR-2B.
Edits after filing
A voucher changed after the return, so the books and return differ.
Deadline week crunch
Sales data arrives late from branches and is keyed in again.
An example: a Coimbatore pump parts maker
Take an illustrative 60-person manufacturer selling to dealers in four states. Branch invoices reached the accountant by email, and each month two days went into rebuilding GSTR-1 and matching purchase credit by hand before the CA uploaded anything.
One month's returns, from invoice to lock
Invoices raised
Branches bill with GSTIN and place of supply.
GSTR-1 prepared
Built from the month's sales records.
GSTR-2B matched
Portal download reconciled with bills.
GSTR-3B derived
Outward tax and eligible credit carried over.
Period locked
Filed with the reference noted, then frozen.
The CA received a ready export and a readable summary on the ninth instead of the eighteenth. Three supplier bills missing from GSTR-2B were held back from the credit claim, and a late branch invoice was picked up by preparing the return again before it was filed.
How GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B software works in Apragya
Step 1 of 5
Source records
Sales invoices carry GSTIN validation, HSN and place of supply.
- Source records: Sales invoices carry GSTIN validation, HSN and place of supply.
- GSTR-1 build: Sections built from the period's invoices, exported for upload.
- GSTR-2B match: The portal download is matched with recorded supplier bills.
- GSTR-3B summary: Derived from the GSTR-1 build and matched credit.
- Period status: Open, prepared, filed and locked, with a snapshot of what was sent.
Tally or Apragya for GST return preparation software in India?
Tally is fast and familiar for an accountant who keys vouchers. Apragya suits teams where sales, purchase and branches create the records themselves. One honest difference: Apragya prepares the return and exports it for upload, rather than filing it from inside the product.
GST returns in Tally and Apragya
| Feature | Tally | Apragya |
|---|---|---|
| Where data comes from | Vouchers entered in Tally | Sales, purchase and accounts apps |
| GSTR-1 | Well established | Built from invoices, JSON and CSV export |
| GSTR-3B | Well established | Derived from GSTR-1 and matched credit |
| Filing on the portal | Check your release's connected features | Export for upload by you or your CA |
| After filing | Depends on your controls | Period locked, with a checksummed snapshot |
| Moving over | Not applicable | Assisted migration at a period start |
Checked against public information on 16 September 2026.
What sets Apragya apart for GST work
GSTIN checks at entry
Customer and supplier GSTINs validated when records are made.
Credit from GSTR-2B
Credit follows what the portal shows, not what was booked.
Frozen filed periods
Corrections go into a later period, as the law expects.
E-invoice and e-way bill
IRN and QR generated from the sales invoice.
Agents with review
An agent can flag mismatches; a person decides.
Assisted migration
Masters and balances moved from Tally at a period start.
See GSTR-1, GSTR-2B reconciliation and our Tally alternative guide.
Trying Apragya beside Tally
- Pick a month that has already been filed from Tally.
- Import that month's customers, suppliers and invoices.
- Prepare GSTR-1 in Apragya and compare the section totals.
- Load the GSTR-2B download and review the unmatched bills.
- Decide whether to move the books at the next period start.
Rebuilding a filed month is the cheapest way to see whether the numbers hold.
What it costs to start
Tally GST filing, answered
Who should stay with Tally for GST?
Does Apragya file returns on the GST portal directly?
Can we correct a return after it is filed?
Will our CA still work with us?
What does it cost to start?
Build this month's GSTR-1 from real records
Rebuild one filed month in Apragya and compare the totals with Tally.