Old Tax Regime vs New Tax Regime: What Is the Difference for Salaried Employees
For employees choosing a regime and for payroll teams deducting TDS on salary: how the two regimes differ and how to run both correctly for a mixed workforce.
Old tax regime vs new tax regime is the question every salaried employee faces in April, and every payroll team has to handle for the whole company. The choice changes how much TDS comes out of each month's salary.
For employers the difficulty is the mix. Some employees choose the new regime and declare nothing. Others choose the old regime and submit rent receipts, insurance and loan certificates that must be checked before the year ends.
This guide explains the difference, shows how to compare the two, and then shows how Apragya Payroll computes TDS for each employee under the regime they picked.
Old tax regime vs new tax regime, in short
India has two ways to compute income tax for individuals. The new regime has lower slab rates and a larger standard deduction, but it disallows most deductions and exemptions. The old regime has higher rates but lets you reduce taxable income with deductions such as the savings and insurance deductions, house rent allowance and interest on a home loan.
The new regime is the default. A salaried person without business income can choose the old regime for a year, and tells the employer at the start so that monthly TDS is deducted on that basis. The final choice can still be made when filing the return. People with business income have tighter limits on switching back and forth.
A worked comparison: two employees each earn the same gross salary. The first claims only small deductions, so the lower new regime rates usually give less tax. The second pays rent in a metro, invests the full savings limit and pays home loan interest, so the old regime may give less tax. The only reliable answer is to compute tax both ways with the current slabs.
The Income-tax Act 2025 applies from 1 April 2026 and renumbers sections, and slabs, rebates and limits are revised in budgets. Check the current figures on the income tax portal before choosing, and treat this page as an explanation, not tax advice.
- Total your expected salary for the year, including bonus and allowances.
- List the deductions and exemptions you can actually claim under the old regime.
- Compute tax under both regimes with the current slabs, rebate and cess.
- Tell your employer your choice at the start of the year for TDS.
- Revisit the comparison when you file, with actual figures.
An example: a Pune software services firm
Take an illustrative 85-person firm where about two thirds of employees pick the new regime. The rest pick the old regime and declare rent, savings and home loan interest.
The year-end checks for one old-regime employee
- Regime chosenOld regime recorded for this tax year.Done
- Rent receiptsMatched to the declared monthly rent.Checked
- Savings proofsPolicy and fund statements uploaded.Checked
- Home loan certificateDeclared in April, not yet submitted.Missing
- TDS recalculatedWaits on the missing certificate.Pending
The employee uploaded the certificate within a week of the reminder. Payroll recalculated TDS on verified figures for the remaining months, so the March deduction was close to every other month's.
How Apragya handles the tax regime choice in payroll
Step 1 of 5
Regimes as data
Old and new regimes, their slabs and allowed exemptions are set per tax year.
- Regimes as data: Old and new regimes, their slabs and allowed exemptions are set per tax year.
- Choice per employee: Each employee's regime is recorded for the year.
- Declarations: Employees declare investments and rent in the tax declaration.
- Proof review: Payroll reviews uploaded proofs before they count as verified.
- Monthly TDS: Tax is annualised and spread over the remaining months.
What a mishandled regime choice costs
Short deduction
TDS under the wrong regime leaves a large bill in the last months.
Unverified proofs
Declared deductions never checked against documents.
March rush
Hundreds of proofs reviewed in the final weeks.
Unhappy staff
A big deduction in March after months of small ones.
Which tax regime is better for salaried people
Neither is better for everyone. The new regime tends to suit people with few deductions and those who prefer simple payslips. The old regime can still suit people with high rent, a home loan and full savings. The payroll system should compute both honestly and let each person choose.
Old and new regimes, side by side
| Feature | Old regime | New regime (both computed in Apragya) |
|---|---|---|
| Slab rates | Higher | Lower, with more slabs |
| Most deductions and exemptions | Allowed | Largely not allowed |
| Standard deduction for salary | Available | Available, and larger |
| Default | Must be chosen | Applies unless you opt out |
| Paperwork | Proofs for each deduction | Very little |
Checked against public information on 16 September 2026.
What sets Apragya apart for TDS on salary
One employee record
Salary, declarations and payslips sit on the same person.
Self-service
Employees declare and upload proofs from a phone-friendly web app.
PII masking
PAN and bank details are masked for people who should not see them.
Audit log
Who changed a declaration or approved a proof is logged.
Statutory deductions
PF, ESI, PT and LWF in the same run.
AI you can put to work
An agent can list employees whose proofs are still missing.
See tax declaration, investment proof review and the detailed new vs old tax regime rules. For deduction mechanics read TDS on salary.
Getting started with regime choices in payroll
- Set up the regimes and slabs for the current tax year.
- Ask every employee to record a regime in April.
- Collect declarations from old-regime employees.
- Set a proof deadline well before the last quarter.
- Review proofs and let TDS adjust over the remaining months.
An early proof deadline is the simplest way to avoid a heavy March deduction.
What it costs to start
New regime deductions allowed and other questions
Which deductions are allowed in the new regime?
Can a salaried employee switch every year?
What if an employee does not choose?
Does the regime affect PF or ESI?
What does it cost to start?
Run TDS on each employee's own regime
Record regime choices, collect declarations and let monthly TDS follow them.